Abstract: I wanted a place that has relative values of the different lips of the TS wheels in one place. Also, I wanted to discuss an approach that would allow you to mimic the MKS wheel size as best one could with the 17in TS wheels.
Specifications:
First, read the background on Style 21 TS wheel:
http://bimmer.roadfly.com/e31/…e/msgsy2001w05/12223.html (Special thanks to Tony for finding the link!)
Here are specification of the key variants Style 21 throwing star wheels and MK Wheels (E32 spec is ignored due to its offsets):
E31 Spec Style 21 TS Wheels:
17x8 ET10 theoretical-lip: 91.6mm
17x9 ET19 theoretical-lip: 95.3mm
E34 Spec Style 21 TS Wheels:
17x8 ET20 theoretical-lipt: 81.6mm
17x9 ET22 theoretical-lip: 92.3mm
E31 Spec MK Motorsport Wheels
18x9.5 ET5 theoretical-lip: 115.65mm
18x11 ET21 theoretical-lip: 118.7mm
Notes:
- "theoretical-lip" - An approximation of the lip independent of size...it is the distance from the front edge to the wheel mounting point (ie wheel width in mm / 2 - offset) THIS DOES NOT TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THE THICKNESS OF THE CENTER IN ANYWAY AND CAN NOT BE USED TO COMPARE BETWEEN DIFFERENT STYLE WHEELS This only works in this case because the center thickness (ie hub and spokes of the wheel) can be assumed to be constant between the different TS Wheels (ie the center is the same between different TS wheels, its location along the central axis is what changes, and thus gives an idea of relative changes)
- I used the MK Motorsport wheels as a benchmark of the largest sizes possible without clearance issues.
Discussion:
First note that the E31 spec wheels TS wheels have a greater theoretical lip then the E34 spec wheels...so much so that the rears of the M5 have only a touch more lip then the E31 fronts! (Difference of 0.7mm or less then 1/32 an inch!)
Using 17x9 Rear Wheels in the Front
I considered using the rears all around. I am still not sure if it will clear the front strut unspaced. Will check later. Either way, I know I can use 12mm spacers to get the offset to a nice ET7. Using 10mm spacers it comes down to ET9, also fine. Do not use anything less then 10mm spacers with proper bolts.
Extending the Rear wheels
I did the calculations, and widening the rear wheels by 1 in will still be ok. The MKS wheels total internal lip is 160.7mm, compared to 133.3mm of the 9in ET19 wheel. So you can safely extend the inner edge by one inch and not have clearance issues. Combined with the above, you can have 17x9 Fronts and 17x10 rears.
Extending the Front wheels
Again, I did the calculations, and widening the rear wheels by 1 in will MOST LIKELY still be ok. Again, the MKS wheels total internal lip is 160.7mm, compared to 111.6mm of the 8in ET10 wheel. Extending the inner edge by two inches will MOST LIKELY not have clearance issues, since they are only 1.7mm extension inward relative to the MKS Monster wheels. Still though, combined with the above, you can have 17x9 Fronts and 17x10 rears.
Summary
If you want close to the MKS size, but don't like the style, you can rather easily do a 17x9 Front (using 10/12mm spacers and rear wheels), and 17x10 Rear (widened from a 9in rear using no spacers) or even 17x11 Rears (widened from 9in rear using 20mm rear spacers)